Empire at War Map Creation Challenge!

Check here for announcements from GE High Command affecting one or more divisions!

Moderator: High Command

User avatar
Munro Burton
Posts: 1320
Joined: Mon Aug 22, 2005 4:30 pm
Location: Tausennigan O'benn Thunderhead-class Superfortress "Post-Dated Check Loan"
Contact:

Post by Munro Burton »

That wouldn't work so well for at least three reasons which come to my mind immediately. The first one is that players won't quite face the same enemy every time as they do in TIE/XvT/XWA/GB.

The second one is that not every EaW unit is equal; all three of the mentioned flightsims allocate a different score to each ship type to balance this. A Stormtrooper Company is worth a LOT less than an AT-AT in terms of both combat power and production cost.

Thirdly, if I recall correctly, the end-of-battle results screen only shows twelve type of units per side at any one time(not counting heroes), with a scroller to show the rest. I just counted the units available for the Rebels: seven mobile units, three turrets, one bomber type(Y-wings which are shot down counts), as well as up to nine buildings. That's a possible total of twenty. See this screenshot if you don't understand what I'm talking about. Clearly, it'd require two screenshots to get all the information across, which just doubles the work.

This is largely moot anyway, as the competition is asking for a singleplayer scenario - something similiar to one of the SP campaign missions - and not a generic map which is used as a skirmish or multiplayer map. That's how I read it, anyway.
Master Sergeant Munro Burton
MSG Burton / Gorgon P2L / 2nd Brigade / Imperial Army
[GS] [SS]x4 [BS]x4 [IS] [IS-P] [MoM]x11 [ICC]x10 [IVC-GL]x5 [IVC-SW] [IVC-SL]x3 [IVC-BW] [IVC-BL]x5 [IVM-GB]x2 [IVM-SB] [AAE-PB-5P] [AAE-GB-1P] [LSM-3S] [MoC-3S] [MoX-BG] (SC1) (RG-G1E)

Image
User avatar
Munro Burton
Posts: 1320
Joined: Mon Aug 22, 2005 4:30 pm
Location: Tausennigan O'benn Thunderhead-class Superfortress "Post-Dated Check Loan"
Contact:

Post by Munro Burton »

The EaW Chamber won't open until someone's created such a scenario, so what you're proposing is essentially a Catch-22 situation.

The objective is obvious to me; create a scenario which has a specific storyline, with specific objectives, such as "destroy that, while keeping this alive" or "capture and hold this while killing that."

See any of the missions currently in one of the other categories for ideas. Hell, recreate one of them if you're that incapable of coming up with a storyline - there were missions created with similiar storylines in TIE/XvT/XWA during Outer Sectors to provide cross-platform functionality.
Master Sergeant Munro Burton
MSG Burton / Gorgon P2L / 2nd Brigade / Imperial Army
[GS] [SS]x4 [BS]x4 [IS] [IS-P] [MoM]x11 [ICC]x10 [IVC-GL]x5 [IVC-SW] [IVC-SL]x3 [IVC-BW] [IVC-BL]x5 [IVM-GB]x2 [IVM-SB] [AAE-PB-5P] [AAE-GB-1P] [LSM-3S] [MoC-3S] [MoX-BG] (SC1) (RG-G1E)

Image
User avatar
LCP Appo
Posts: 407
Joined: Sun Mar 18, 2007 1:11 pm
Location: Wherever The Empire needs me.
Contact:

Post by LCP Appo »

I´ve tried to make a good map but the triggers won´t work.
Any idea how to make them work?
LCP Appo/ Raider Company/1st Brigade/ Imperial Army

Protect. Defend. Preserve.

It´s better to live one day as a lion than a hundred years as a sheep.

Through ash and fire, through the darkest deep and the blackest night, through haunted ground and through the gates of hell, I shall follow thou my love, my Empire.

Image
User avatar
LC La Forge
Posts: 2359
Joined: Tue Apr 27, 2004 2:38 am

Post by LC La Forge »

Beat them with a cattle prod then go write your own editor because the one out there is trash. :P
~Lieutenant Commander La Forge
LC La Forge / Iota 1-1 / ISD Chimaera / Imperial Navy
[LoP] [GS] [SS]x4 [BS]x3 [IS-B-2P] [MoM]x5 [IVC-GW] [IVC-SW] [IVC-BW]x2 [IVM-SB] [AAEH-3P] [AAE-PB-2P] [AAE-SB-1P] [LSM-6S] [MoC-6S] [MoT] [MoX]
"As a team, we can do anything and everything.
Believe in this, and we will win!"

Image
User avatar
LCP Appo
Posts: 407
Joined: Sun Mar 18, 2007 1:11 pm
Location: Wherever The Empire needs me.
Contact:

Post by LCP Appo »

That´s no way to get a medal.
Besides, there got to be a way to make it work.
Only problem is I´m soon gonna smash the dam game into pieces.
ARGH!!!!
LCP Appo/ Raider Company/1st Brigade/ Imperial Army

Protect. Defend. Preserve.

It´s better to live one day as a lion than a hundred years as a sheep.

Through ash and fire, through the darkest deep and the blackest night, through haunted ground and through the gates of hell, I shall follow thou my love, my Empire.

Image
User avatar
Munro Burton
Posts: 1320
Joined: Mon Aug 22, 2005 4:30 pm
Location: Tausennigan O'benn Thunderhead-class Superfortress "Post-Dated Check Loan"
Contact:

Post by Munro Burton »

Appo wrote:That´s no way to get a medal.
I'm fairly sure you'd get something better than a SS if you made an editor that's user-friendly. :P
Master Sergeant Munro Burton
MSG Burton / Gorgon P2L / 2nd Brigade / Imperial Army
[GS] [SS]x4 [BS]x4 [IS] [IS-P] [MoM]x11 [ICC]x10 [IVC-GL]x5 [IVC-SW] [IVC-SL]x3 [IVC-BW] [IVC-BL]x5 [IVM-GB]x2 [IVM-SB] [AAE-PB-5P] [AAE-GB-1P] [LSM-3S] [MoC-3S] [MoX-BG] (SC1) (RG-G1E)

Image
User avatar
LCP Appo
Posts: 407
Joined: Sun Mar 18, 2007 1:11 pm
Location: Wherever The Empire needs me.
Contact:

Post by LCP Appo »

Yeah good luck with that!
(Unless you noted I was being sarcastic)
LCP Appo/ Raider Company/1st Brigade/ Imperial Army

Protect. Defend. Preserve.

It´s better to live one day as a lion than a hundred years as a sheep.

Through ash and fire, through the darkest deep and the blackest night, through haunted ground and through the gates of hell, I shall follow thou my love, my Empire.

Image
Post Reply